Recent essays:

No Dice

Maximum Cat

A Modest Proposal

Other articles:

The Evaporating Editorial Cartoonist

Have Fun Stormin' the Castle!

Gimme That Ol' Time Rollerball

A Guide to Middle-earth

Reviews:

Revenge of the Sith (2005)

Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy (2005)

The Egyptologist (2004)

Prague (2003)

 

Interviews:

Ted Rall: Next Stop, Central Asia (2006)

 

 

 

[The following article appeared in The Herald-Sun in December 2001.]

A Guide to Middle-earth

J.R.R. Tolkien's masterpiece continues to enthrall audiences

By J.P. Trostle

Long before Harry Potter and Hogwarts and muggles, there were ... Hobbits.

   Also elves and dwarves and dragons and orcs, eagles that could talk and trees that could walk, the great wizard Gandalf and the Dark Lord Sauron -- and a pesky little ring that could give its wearer dominance over all of Middle-earth. But especially, there were hobbits.

   For more than 60 years, millions of readers have embraced the imaginary world created by J.R.R. Tolkien in his novels "The Hobbit" and "The Lord of the Rings." Millions more will be introduced to the denizens of Middle-earth Wednesday when "The Fellowship of the Ring," the first of three films adapting the epic "Lord of the Rings," comes to the big screen in theaters around the world.

   Perhaps "epic" is too small a word to describe the upcoming trilogy of films. As directed by New Zealander Peter Jackson, it is by far the largest movie production ever undertaken. With a reported cost of $275 million and a shooting schedule of 274 days - both records - all three movies were filmed at the same time in more than 100 locations across New Zealand with the proverbial cast of thousands. (Adding together cast, crew and extras, more than 23,000 people have labored on the project since preproduction began in 1997.) Although principal cinema-photography is complete, work on the special effects will continue over the next two years as the second film, "The Two Towers," is released in December 2002, and "The Return of the King" completes the story in December 2003.

   What story could inspire so many people to labor so long?

   "The Lord of the Rings" is a sprawling saga of good and evil set in the mythical realm. Against a backdrop of clashing armies, a small band of heroes sets out on a desperate quest to destroy a Dark Lord's main weapon, a magic ring that gives him control over all creation.

   Although Hollywood first approached Tolkien about adapting his work in the 1950s (he turned them down because they misspelled many of his characters' names in the proposal), the sheer scale of the project has discouraged anyone from attempting a live-action film until now.

***

Just what is a hobbit?

   A professor of language and literature at Oxford University, John Ronald Reuel Tolkien introduced readers to Middle-earth in 1937 with his publication of "The Hobbit." Though touted as a whimsical children's story, it had a sophistication and depth which engaged adult readers on another level.

   In it he tells the tale of Bilbo Baggins, a hobbit of some means who lives in The Shire. Hobbits, according to Tolkien, are a smallish people a little over three feet high who love nothing more than to laugh and eat (up to six meals a day). They are a simple, earthy folk, good at growing things, living in comfortable tunnels under the ground and padding about barefoot on large, furry feet.

   Bilbo has no greater ambition than to enjoy the good things in life and certainly doesn't want any adventures.

   Yet one afternoon he is paid a visit by his friend Gandalf the Wizard, and against his better judgment, allows himself to be pushed into a quest that changes his life. He accompanies a band of dwarves hoping to reclaim their ancestral home under The Lonely Mountain from the terrible dragon Smaug. Along the way Bilbo has many wondrous and strange adventures and eventually returns to The Shire with a great treasure, including a magic sword and a ring that turns the wearer invisible.

   "The Hobbit" was gladly greeted by most critics and had enough commercial success that Tolkien's publisher wanted more. Tolkien already had an idea for a sequel but quickly realized it would be far darker and mature in theme than would be suited for a children's book.

***

A tour of Middle-earth

   World War II and his responsibilities as a professor pushed the delivery date on his new novel back over a decade and a half, and by the time it was done "The Lord of the Rings" weighed in at more than 1,200 pages. The publisher decided to break the book into three parts and part one of the trilogy, "The Fellowship of the Ring," was released in 1954.

   Dealing with the magic ring Bilbo brought back with him, "The Lord of the Rings" picks up 60 years after "The Hobbit," and allowed Tolkien to explore the width and breadth of his creation in amazing and poetic detail.

   Although breathtakingly beautiful, the medieval-like Middle-earth is a land in turmoil and decline. Travel and trade have become difficult and dangerous. The stately, eternal elves, once prevalent throughout the countryside, have retreated to a few, carefully guarded, wooded enclaves. Stout, hardy dwarves wander far and wide attempting to recapture their glory days, before they were driven out of their underground cities by fire-breathing dragons and demonic Balrogs.

   In the south, the kingdom of Gondor has begun to fight a desperate holding action against armies of orcs from the nearby land of Mordor, a place so corrupt and evil nothing there will grow. In the north, where the kingdoms of Man have long since fallen into ruin, only the self-appointed Rangers keep the peace, allowing communities like The Shire and Bree to thrive.

   An ancient evil has returned: Sauron, believed vanquished thousands of years before, has once again taken form. From his ancient citadel in Mordor, he seeks the magical ring that was cut from his hand at his first defeat, and lost to history shortly thereafter.

   Though not initially a best seller, "The Lord of the Rings" met with rave reviews and continued to sell briskly over the years as word of mouth spread. When, in the mid-1960s, an unscrupulous American publisher attempted to exploit a loophole in copyright laws and release a paperback version in the United States without Tolkien's permission, it sold 100,000 copies.

   While Tolkien was quite incensed, it showed there was growing interest in the work. His official publisher put out new versions of the books, and the title became a perennial best seller. Since 1956 when "The Return of the King," the third part of the trilogy, was released, "The Lord of the Rings" has sold more than 50 million copies.

*** 

The Good Professor

   J.R.R. Tolkien grew up near Birmingham, England, at the turn of the century. Early in his education Tolkien became fascinated with mythology and began to experiment with creating his own legends and poems. While convalescing after contracting trench fever in World War I, Tolkien began to write the first stories that would make up the history of Middle-earth.

   After the war his first job was as an assistant lexicographer on the "Oxford English Dictionary," and he eventually became a professor at the University of Leeds, teaching Middle English and medieval mythology.

   Tolkien loved words and their origins and embraced linguistics with great enthusiasm. As a mental exercise, he invented his own languages. Knowing full well language doesn't exist in a vacuum but is affected by time and place and the interactions of people, he began to knit together many of his tales and ideas and imaginary tongues into a single, comprehensive setting.

   By the late 1920s, Tolkien had earned a coveted teaching position at Pembroke College in Oxford. During this time he helped form The Inklings, an informal group of teachers and writers that included his good friend C.S. Lewis. The group would meet to socialize and often read to each other from works in progress. It was here he received feedback and encouragement in his continuously growing project.

   Tolkien was a prolific writer and he had already mapped out in his mind a loose history of three "ages" of his mythical land. But he was also a perfectionist and did not like to publish anything before it had been finely polished. After "The Lord of the Rings" was finished he continued to work on, but never finished, several books' worth of stories set in Middle-earth. Indeed, his son Christopher has practically made a career out of editing and publishing Tolkien's copious notes, putting out more than 14 volumes of material since his father's death in 1973.

   What accounts for the long-term appeal of J.R.R. Tolkien's work? It has a widespread popularity beyond that of a mere "sword and sorcery" tale.

   Perhaps it is his incredible attention to detail - including nine fully formed languages and elaborate maps and timelines - which help makes his creation so believable. ("The Return of the King" comes with six appendices alone, covering everything from how to properly pronounce the elven and dwarfen tongues to complete family trees of hundreds of characters. It should be noted, none of these are required reading, but add greatly in persuading readers they are looking at a real history and not a work of fiction.)

   In creating his own epic, Tolkien drew heavily on his knowledge of existing sagas such as "Beowulf" and "King Arthur," and many of the ideas in his writings were inspired by stories from Celtic and Norse legends. As stated by Ruth Noel in her book, "The Mythology of Middle-earth," "The sense of depth in Tolkien's works has its source in the author's understanding and selective use of the ancient themes from mythology. [This] has a profound effect on the reader [and] is not accidental. Mythic themes deal with basic challenges that face man universally ... such as love, fate and death."

   Beyond such high ideas however, J.R.R. Tolkien loved nothing more than spinning a good yarn. As he said in the foreword to "The Fellowship of the Ring," he relished the opportunity to "try his hand at a really long story that would hold the attention of readers, amuse them, delight them and at times maybe excite them or deeply move them."

   Millions of readers - and now moviegoers - will agree he succeeded.

***

Who's Who in The Fellowship

   To prevent the One Ring from falling into the hands of the Dark Lord, nine heroes join together on a desperate quest:

   Gandalf. A wizard of great renown, it has fallen to him to rally the many peoples of Middle-earth against the return of Sauron.

   Aragorn. A ranger of the north - and the last heir to the throne - he must rid the land of evil before he may claim his birthright.

   Legolas. A skilled archer and the son of an elven-king, he is chosen to represent his people in the Fellowship.

   Gimli. A stout dwarven warrior, he must put his distrust of elves aside in this time of strife.

   Boromir. A warrior of Gondor, he has come north seeking aid against the creatures that pour forth from Mordor in increasing numbers.

   Frodo. A hobbit from The Shire, he is about to discover the true nature of the ring he inherited from his cousin, Bilbo.

   Samwise. Frodo's gardener and faithful servant, Sam will protect his master against any threat, even if it costs him his life.

   Merry and Pippin. Frodo's cousins and closest friends, they are determined to help the Ringbearer on his journey, no matter where it takes him - even into the evil wastelands of Mordor itself.